Money matters

Controlling the urge to splurge: Car-buying strategies for new DOs

After years in med school and residency, the desire to spend is strong for new doctors. Before splurging on a fancy new car, heed this advice.

Medical students and residents toil for years, learning their profession and delaying gratification. So, it’s no surprise that many newly minted DOs can’t wait to spend a buck or two.

“New doctors have a lot of pent-up consumption, so it’s natural that they would want to splurge a little,” says Chris Chen, a certified financial planner with Insight Financial Strategists in Waltham, Massachusetts.

A sparkling new luxury car often tops the list. Not only can a set of hot wheels feel like a well-earned reward, but it also serves as a status symbol, a visible sign that you’ve finally “made it.”
But giving into temptation and plunking down a wad of cash on a BMW or a Lexus can be a terrible financial mistake, Chen says.

“I never recommend that a new DO or MD buy a luxury anything in the early years,” he says.

During a doctor’s first few years on the job, spending opportunities often arrive “in quick succession”–from marriage and kids, to a monthly payment on a new house, Chen says. In addition, most doctors also carry a lot of debt from their years in medical school.

“The first order of business has to be to reduce the debt–maybe not eliminate, but at least reduce,” Chen says.

For that reason, Chen typically advises new doctors to keep the car they used in residency a bit longer whenever possible.

“It’s important that people have priorities, and a luxury car has to be at the bottom,” he says.

A smarter way to buy a car

New DOs who need a car should settle for something more modest, Chen says. Other financial advisers agree.

“There are happy mediums between an economical car and a luxury car,” says Alexander Koury, a certified financial planner with Householder Group in Scottsdale, Arizona. “Your decision does not have to be all or nothing.”

If you’re determined to buy a luxury car, consider one that is not brand new, says Adam Kozak, a certified financial planner at KPL Financial Group in Eastchester, New York.

“I recommend they buy a 2- to 3-year-old luxury car off-lease or from a car rental company,” Kozak says. He says such cars typically cost about 30 percent less than a new car. Plus, you avoid the significant depreciation a car experiences in the first year after it leaves the car lot.

Leasing a car also can make sense for some new doctors, especially those who like the “new car” feel and prefer to update every few years.

However, before leasing, have a good gauge of how many miles you drive annually. Leases typically come with mileage limits of around 15,000 miles over two or three years. Exceed the limit, and you’ll end up paying extra fees.

If you work as a contractor or have your own solo practice, some of the costs associated with buying or leasing a car might be tax-deductible. Sit down with a tax professional to find out which options apply to you.

Avoiding the siren song of luxury

Of course, some new doctors just can’t help being drawn in by the siren song of a brand-new luxury vehicle. However, rushing out to buy a flashy set of wheels can establish a bad pattern of overspending that can haunt a doctor for years to come.

Koury has been working with one doctor for more than a decade who had a lot of student debt upon leaving school, but bought a luxury car and expensive house soon after beginning to practice. Those decisions have hurt the doctor financially.

“He is no better off today than he was when he started working,” Koury says. He adds that the situation is common among doctors. “He thought a big salary would solve his problems,” he says.

Allan Katz, a certified financial planner and founder of Comprehensive Wealth Management Group in Staten Island, New York, encourages physicians to initially focus on making a significant dent in their debt load before looking down the road to buying a luxury vehicle.

Until then, Katz encourages new doctors to keep things in proper perspective.

“In reality, nobody really cares what car you drive,” Katz says. “When patients come to your office, the last thing they are thinking about is the cars in the parking lot.”

4 comments

  1. There is a financial advisor who has a radio program call Financial Peace. Dave Ramsey went into bankruptcy as a young real estate “tycoon” & built his life back from what he learned. Bottom line is he hates debt especially for school but that’s a different discussion at this point for most of you.
    I believe Dave would tell you to keep living like you are poor and pay off your loans first. Basicly you are poor (except for your education in your head) until all of your loans are paid off. The last thing you need to do is to add to them.
    I know this sounds ridiculous to most of you & yes you have earned a better style of living. You need to balance the books before that happens. There have been many wonderful days in my family’s life, one of the absolute best being the day I paid off my last loan. Used cars, modest housing, kids educated, debt-free & financial freedom in middle age, close to heaven.
    Any of Dave Ramsey’s books can be found at most book stores & his company runs a training program in many cities & towns called Financial Peace University. Find one and sign up. And no I have no monetary interest in this whatsoever other than to help you be free men & women, also.

  2. Dave Ramsey is good for those who are in a poor financial situation after poor financial decisions. But Dave Ramsey would recommend you not going to medical school in the first place given the amount of debt you have to incur. My recommendation would be the White Coat Investor; blog, book, podcast, or all three. He has guidance for those who are still in medical school all the way through practicing physicians.

    But really it all boils down to leave below your means.

  3. It is really a shame that MD/DO can’t buy a nice car after completing their GME. Unfortunately, the way things currently stand, any financial opportunity to spend money is taken away by the ridiculous tuition so many of these schools charge. Especially DO schools, they seem to be the worst, providing low quality education and excessively high tuition.

    1. Not sure where you went to school but many if not all DO schools provide comparable education to the MD counterparts or better. Michigan State is routinely ranked in the top 10 of ALL medical schools in primary care. High academic positions are held or have been held by DOs from across the spectrum of Osteopathic schools.
      Do you have any evidence that the Osteopathic schools are more expensive? Many are private and private schools are more expensive generally. Links of a comparable analysis please.

      Also it depends what you define as a “nice car” I doubt that one could afford a brand new Mercedes S class after GME but I certainly know that if you are prudent with your borrowing, saving money during undergrad and search out used car deals I know that many excellent “nice cars” can be had for 20k or less. Some of which are luxury brands just a few years old.

Leave a comment Please see our comment policy