Passing the baton

The importance of mentoring tomorrow’s colleagues today

“Over the past few years, mentorship has become one of the most rewarding parts of my medical school experience,” writes Kelly McGowen, OMS IV, who shares how she has mentored premeds.

Topics

The first time I mentored a group of premedical students, I expected to spend the day answering questions about medicine. Instead, I quickly realized that nearly every conversation came back to the same underlying question: How do I know if I’m ready to apply to medical school?

Some students asked about grades, others wanted feedback on their personal statements or activities section and some wondered whether they had enough clinical experience or research. Although the questions varied, they all reflected the same uncertainty that so many of us remember feeling before we started medical school.

Even as a fourth-year medical student, I can still remember what it felt like to apply. Medicine can feel like an impossible mountain to climb when you’re standing at the bottom. It can seem like a world with invisible rules, where every application requirement feels daunting and everyone else appears to have the answers while you’re still trying to figure out how to move forward.

For many pre-medical students, especially students who are the first in their families pursuing a career in this field or those who have limited access to mentors, the path feels overwhelming.

We all have mentoring abilities

As medical students, it’s easy to underestimate how valuable our perspective is to those just beginning this journey. We spend so much time looking ahead to the next exam, rotation or milestone that we sometimes forget we’ve already been on a journey someone else is just starting.

Not long ago, we were the students wondering how to study for the MCAT, whether our experiences were enough or whether we truly belonged in medicine.

One of the most important lessons I’ve learned is that you don’t need to be an expert to become a mentor. In fact, being only a few steps ahead can be one of your greatest strengths. We still remember refreshing the application portal, preparing for interviews, questioning our competitiveness and celebrating the small victories that ultimately led us to medical school. Since those experiences are still fresh, our perspective is uniquely valuable to aspiring physicians navigating the same process.

Over the past few years, mentorship has become one of the most rewarding parts of my medical school experience. Through outreach programs at my medical school, mentorship organizations like Pre-SOMA (Student Osteopathic Medical Association) and conversations with aspiring physicians preparing to apply, I’ve learned that every student arrives with a unique story.

What surprised me most was that, despite their different journeys, many of our conversations centered on the same message: there isn’t one “perfect” applicant. Instead, we are helping students authentically frame their experiences in a way that reflects who they are and the physician they hope to become.

Those conversations changed the way I think about mentorship. Effective mentorship isn’t about providing all the answers or encouraging someone to follow the same path you did. It’s about helping students reflect on their experiences, recognize the strengths they’ve already developed and feel confident sharing the story that only they can tell.

To me, mentorship isn’t measured by how many questions you answer, but by whether someone walks away with greater confidence in their own story.

There isn’t one experience that defines a future physician, and mentorship should reflect that reality. The journey to medicine isn’t linear. Some students take gap years, others pursue entirely different careers before medical school and some discover medicine later than expected. When students see mentors with diverse experiences, they’re more likely to recognize that there’s room for their own story in this field.

Mentorship also benefits us as future physicians. Medical school has a way of narrowing our focus at times. There is always another exam to study for, another rotation to prepare for or another deadline approaching.

Mentorship offers an opportunity to step outside that cycle. As I prepare for residency, it has reminded me to reflect on how far I’ve come in my own journey and reconnect with the reasons I chose medicine in the first place.

One mentee’s journey brought that reflection into focus. She sought my mentorship after her first medical school application was unsuccessful. As we reviewed her application, we identified ways she could continue growing, including gaining more clinical experience and exploring interests outside of medicine. One experience she later shared with me came from her work as a medical assistant—a patient seemed unsure how to raise a concern during an appointment. As she took the patient’s vitals and asked intake questions, she gave them time to explain what was on their mind and helped them feel comfortable raising the concern with the physician.

Her compassion and willingness to listen were already part of who she was. Reflecting on the encounter helped her articulate how feeling seen can shape a patient’s experience of care. It also gave her a concrete example to draw on as she described the physician she hoped to become and how she would carry that lesson into her own practice.

Over time, our conversations helped her connect experiences like this to her reasons for pursuing medicine and speak with greater confidence about what she had learned from them. When she was later accepted to medical school, I felt proud of what she had accomplished and grateful to have witnessed her growth. Seeing her grow as an applicant and as a person brought me back to my own path and to the reasons I chose medicine.

The connection between mentoring and patient care

Teaching, listening, encouraging and communicating are all skills we carry directly into patient care. Just as importantly, mentoring reminds us that the future of medicine is built long before residency or practice. The students we encourage today will one day become our classmates, residents, colleagues and collaborators.

Investing in their growth isn’t simply about helping someone earn an acceptance, but rather it’s about helping shape the profession we’ll one day share together.

Mentorship doesn’t require a formal title, years of experience or a perfect understanding of the admissions process. It simply requires a willingness to invest in someone else’s journey. Medical students can make a meaningful difference by:

  • Volunteering with pipeline or outreach programs at their medical school
  • Mentoring through student organizations, such as local or national Pre-SOMA
  • Speaking with undergraduate pre-health clubs
  • Reviewing personal statements, CVs or conducting mock interviews
  • Sharing honest perspectives about medical school and remaining available to answer questions from aspiring physicians

Many of us remember the people who answered an email, reviewed an application, offered encouragement after a setback or simply took the time to believe in us before we fully believed in ourselves. Whether those relationships lasted years or only a single conversation, they helped shape our path to medicine.

Now we have the opportunity to do the same for someone else. Looking back, I don’t think any of us ever felt completely ready when we submitted our medical school applications. Most of us were buoyed by people who encouraged us through uncertainty and reminded us that we belonged in medicine.

Editor’s note: Mentorship opportunities are available on AOiA’s Emerging DO platform for medical students, residents and DOs. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily represent the views of The DO or the AOA.

Leave a comment Please see our comment policy