Leading with empathy

Blaming vs. supporting: 5 tips to address noncompliance with compassion

Kyle Bringhurst, OMS IV, shares how lessons from his previous job inspired him to focus on solutions when working with noncompliant patients.

Topics

Editor’s note: The patient’s name in this article has been changed for privacy purposes.

Before entering medicine, I worked in manufacturing, where I learned important lessons about safety culture. When an axle fell from a hoist on our production line, my team didn’t ask, “Who’s at fault?” Instead, our team asked: “What went wrong—and how do we keep it from happening again?”

When approaching incident investigations, it can be too easy or even natural to find who’s at fault. When an investigation identifies employee behavior as the root cause, that often stops the investigation short and leads to shortsighted solutions.

In this case, we could’ve asked who was at fault for the axle falling and would’ve found that the operator was rushed in his duties and didn’t properly engage the locking mechanism; however, if we stopped there, we would’ve missed more valuable and robust fixes to the axle falling.

That single shift in perspective revealed multiple contributing factors—a design flaw, a missing spring in the locking mechanism and limitations in the automation system. By focusing on solutions instead of blaming, we made the environment safer for everyone; but more importantly, we got greater buy-in and trust from the production, maintenance and engineering teams.

The role of behavior

I once worked with a patient, Mr. S., who was making a sincere effort to improve his health. He had changed his diet, started exercising, lost weight and expressed hope about reducing his medication. I noticed his attentive posture and steady eye contact—clear signs that he was committed to making a change. Still, there was a puzzling disconnect: his in-office blood pressure readings remained elevated, yet he described symptoms more consistent with low blood pressure.

We couldn’t determine whether this discrepancy was due to his new habits, recent medication adjustments or another factor. Despite having previously discussed the importance of tracking his blood pressure, no log had been kept, leaving us without the data we needed to make an informed decision.

I’ll admit, I felt a little powerless—how can we address this blood pressure level and complaints if the only measurement we have is high? Instead of letting those feelings take over, I paused and tried to approach the situation with empathy and collaboration.

“To make sure we’re on the right dose, I’d like you to keep a daily blood pressure log,” I said to Mr. S. “This will help us see whether your lifestyle changes are working or if we need to adjust your medication. What can we do to help you achieve this goal, or what obstacles might get in the way?”

We talked through his morning routine and realized that if he took his medication first thing, there would be just enough time for it to take effect before he left for work—making it easier to get a reliable blood pressure reading each day. By working together to find a practical solution, we turned a potential point of frustration into an opportunity for partnership and progress.

The problem with blame

A powerful example of blame in healthcare can be seen in the early years of the HIV/AIDS epidemic. When HIV/AIDS first emerged in the 1980s, it was stigmatized and associated with marginalized groups, leading to a slow public health response. This stigma resulted in underfunding for research and delayed efforts to address the epidemic, as policymakers and parts of the medical community were hesitant to act.

It wasn’t until HIV was found to be transmissible through blood transfusions and to affect people outside the initially identified groups that the medical community and government began to respond more broadly and ethically.

This history shows how blaming patients for their illness—whether due to lifestyle, identity or circumstance—can hinder care and delay progress. Today, while it’s rare for clinicians to refuse treatment to patients with conditions like lung cancer due to smoking or an abdominal aortic aneurysm due to nonadherence, subtle forms of blame and stigma can still influence care decisions.

Research suggests that empathetic clinician-patient relationships may support better clinical outcomes. In a study of 891 patients with diabetes, patients of physicians with high empathy scores were more likely to have good control of hemoglobin A1c and LDL cholesterol than patients of physicians with low empathy scores—showing us how focusing on understanding and support, rather than blaming, can be beneficial for our patients.

Parallels in medicine

We all encounter patients whose lifestyle choices contribute to their illness. I speak for myself and countless other physicians who entered medicine to make a difference in people’s lives. That sense of impact is what makes medicine rewarding and worth the time and effort we put in to get here.

So it can be tempting to feel frustrated when patients are noncompliant with treatment regimens. It is tempting to feel that our work is done in vain. But giving into these feelings can lead to us blaming our patients for their illnesses, which can result in patients becoming defensive, shutting down or refusing further treatment.

A no-blame approach reframes the conversation—when a patient with uncontrolled diabetes admits they forget their medication and haven’t made any of the lifestyle modifications previously discussed, instead of criticism, we can offer support: “We’ve asked you to make some big changes to your life. What is preventing you from making the changes we’ve discussed and how can we support you in making these changes?”

As osteopathic physicians, this approach aligns with our philosophy. Treating the whole person—body, mind and spirit—means looking beyond the behavior to understand the barriers behind it. It builds trust, encourages open communication and helps patients feel safe discussing their challenges.

Tactics for supporting patients

Clinicians can move from blame to support when working with patients by doing the following:

  • Use direct, compassionate communication that supports—not shames—the patient.
  • Explore the reasons behind a behavior before focusing on the behavior itself.
  • Invite honest dialogue, especially when patients struggle with adherence.
  • Collaborate on realistic, patient-centered solutions.
  • Reinforce osteopathic principles by building strong, trusting and therapeutic partnerships.

By shifting from blame to understanding, we strengthen patient relationships, improve safety and promote meaningful change. This mindset is not only a safety principle—it reflects the core values of osteopathic medicine.

Editor’s note: The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily represent the views of The DO or the AOA.

Related reading:

How to screen for, diagnose and treat major depressive disorder as a primary care physician

The missing patient file: Kurdish health in the US

Leave a comment Please see our comment policy